Hawai'i Journalism InitiativeHawaiʻi reef insurance used for first time on Maui to repair hundreds of hurricane-damaged corals
When Tiara Stark dove below the surface of a popular West Maui snorkeling spot after Hurricane Lowell, the peaceful underwater paradise looked like it had been run over with a bulldozer.
The storm’s powerful swells had dislodged and torn up key colonies of the reef at Coral Gardens, leaving fields of rubble about two feet deep in places.
“It was just really devastating to be honest,” said Stark, the project manager for The Nature Conservancy’s Maui Marine Program. “I’ve never firsthand seen so much damage, and I think a lot of us were not expecting it.”
Last month, a team of conservationists, government agency staff and community members spent four days reattaching 779 corals to the reefs at Coral Gardens and Mākena Landing, where both storm surge and a boat grounding damaged the reef.

The repairs to the Maui corals after Hurricanes Lala and Lowell were covered by a $500,000 payout by The Nature Conservancy’s coral reef insurance policy, marking the first time it has been used since the organization purchased the policy in 2022. At the time, it was the first coral reef insurance policy in the United States.
The Nature Conservancy and its partners also developed the world’s first reef insurance policy related to hurricane damage in Mexico in 2019.
Stark said the insurance “is a huge game-changer.”
“So much goes into an emergency coral restoration response,” she said. “The amount of people that you need, not just in the water, but behind the scenes, the amount of supplies you actually need, the vessel support … There’s no way I think we could have made such a big impact if we didn’t have this funding available.”
Dustin Paradis, executive director of the Maui Ocean Center Marine Institute, said the insurance policy helped the groups involved “act fast and keep avoidable coral loss from piling onto the pressures reefs already face.”
“Reefs have always been shaped by storms, but today they’re also coping with sediment, nutrient pollution and warming seas on top of them,” Paradis said in a news release last week. “These corals need a helping hand.”
Hawai‘i’s reefs are critical not just to the marine life they nurture and the local families they feed, but also to the coastlines where they form a barrier that helps curb storm surge. But severe storms can take a toll on live coral, and the loss of just one meter of reef height can double expected annual flood damages, according to The Nature Conservancy.
Repairs aren’t cheap — immediate damage assessment, collection and reattaching of broken corals starts at about $25,000 per acre, and more intensive sustained reef restoration costs even more, The Nature Conservancy said.

Hurricane Lala didn’t do much damage to Maui’s coral reefs when it passed by the islands in late August, but Hurricane Lowell, which followed in early September, left “massive damage,” Stark said.
The statewide coalition of government agencies, scientists, nonprofits and community groups that make up the Hawai‘i Emergency Reef Restoration Network spent years planning and training for incidents like this. They’d already lined up the permits and supplies ahead of time. But Stark said nothing could have tested them as much as the damage from the storms.
After weeks of preparation, a team of snorkelers, scuba divers and swimmers towed behind boats spent two days surveying the damage across West and South Maui, deciding which areas to prioritize for repairs.
Stark led the repair efforts that had to be strategic in choosing the places to spend their energy and funding. They looked for areas that were heavily damaged and also located in places that could seed other reefs in Maui Nui with the help of the currents.
Coral Gardens and Mākena Landing are home to critical reef-building corals and other species of corals that serve as nurseries for smaller fish. Both also are popular recreational spots for snorkeling, diving and fishing.
Molokini Crater, another famed snorkeling spot popular with tour companies, also suffered extensive damage, with broken corals and portions of the island falling onto the reef below. But the sunken crater a few miles offshore wasn’t chosen for repairs because it “wouldn’t have had as much of a benefit” to other areas given the currents, Stark explained. The 6-mile distance from the nearest boat ramp to Molokini Crater also would make it difficult for teams to regularly monitor in the future.
“Even though it was so devastating there and very apparent, we decided not to move forward with response there,” Stark said.

The teams spent Oct. 13 and 14 at Mākena Landing and Oct. 21 and 22 at Coral Gardens. Crews mixed and bagged balls of cement for snorkelers to deliver to the divers, who chose areas with no live coral to scrub clean of algae and attach pieces of coral. They used an epoxy mix for smaller fragments. At Mākena Landing, some repairs required drilling and pinning because the surge was so strong and there had been a lot of degradation from sea urchins.
Five boat captains and 29 people participated in the work.
To make sure their work actually benefited the reef, the teams left some “control plots” untouched so they could return to monitor them and compare the naturally recovering coral growth to the reef helped by human intervention.
The Hawai‘i Department of Land and Natural Resources’ Division of Aquatic Resources has been monitoring Mākena Landing, and Stark said some reattached corals have been dislodged and others “looked bleached just from the stress.” She pointed out that not every coral that was reattached is going to survive, which is why tracking the recovery is so important.
“There’s just so much that we’re going to learn, I think, from this response and the responses statewide, so that we can only get better at increasing the success … during these reattachment efforts,” Stark said.

As for the damaged coral that couldn’t be repaired, such as the reef at Molokini Crater, Stark said the reef could recover on its own, but the process will be slow, with corals taking years to grow.
“Obviously we’ve had coral reefs for a very long time,” she said. “I kind of have the mindset of like, reefs are resilient and may not look the same or be the same. But I think that I’m hopeful.”
And, they’re still racing to save whatever corals they can. Stark said the organization is seeking additional funding — likely less than $10,000 — from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s Coral Emergency Restoration Fund to do more repairs, though “the window is limited.”
Stark explained: “The longer you wait, the less corals are going to be able to be saved.”


