Maui News

Maui Police Commission votes against reinstating the chief during temporary investigation

Play
Listen to this Article
4 minutes
Loading Audio... Article will play after ad...
Playing in :00
A
A
A

Maui Police Chief John Pelletier (right) and his attorney Eric Seitz (left). PC: Wendy Osher (11.18.26)

The Maui Police Commission voted Wednesday against reinstating Police Chief John Pelletier while an investigation is underway into his oversight of the department’s Criminal Intelligence Unit. The 6-1 vote came as the commission discussed an Oct. 9, 2026 letter from Pelletier’s Attorney Eric Seitz, demanding that his client be reinstated from leave with pay pending investigation.

Also during the Nov. 18 meeting, the commission voted 7-0 in favor of launching a second independent investigation into Chief Pelletier to determine if allegations of general order violations warrant disciplinary removal.

The scope of the investigation would focus on:

  • Statements made at Chief John Pelletierʻs press conference on Oct. 9, 2026, and any subsequent related media statements by Pelletier.
  • Allegations that Pelletier: stopped attending executive cabinet meetings for all directors, stopped giving briefings to the mayor on matters of importance, removed the mayor’s name from MPD official letterhead, and is working a schedule without police commission awareness or approval.

Pelletier was placed on paid administrative leave during the previous commission meeting on Oct. 7, 2026.

Commission Chair explains initial reasoning for placing chief on leave with pay

Commission Chair Frank Tam. PC: Wendy Osher (11.18.26)

Commission Chair Frank Tam explained the reasons the commission took action on Oct. 7, pointing to the commission’s power to appoint and remove the chief as outlined in the Maui County Charter.

He said the Hawaiʻi Appellate Court has held (Kauaʻi Police Commission v. Carvalho 2016) that the power to appoint and remove “includes other lesser supervisory powers over the chief, such as suspending the chief, or placing the chief on leave pending investigation.”

“Our commission takes its role as supervisory authority over the chief of police very seriously,” said Tam. “The commission decided to place the chief on leave pending investigation because it believed his presence at work would be detrimental to the conduct of the independent investigation on the operations of the department.”

According to Tam, the commission felt Pelletier’s failure to attend the Aug. 19 2026 Police Commission meeting following the arrest of Lieutenant Michael Vaituulala, “showed lack of transparency, lack of communication, poor leadership, lack of concern for the seriousness of the allegations, and lack of accountability.”

Tam said there was “a need to protect the integrity of the investigation, which was based on serious federal criminal corruption charges against the head of the Criminal Intelligence Unit, when the CIU directly reported to the chief.”

He said there was also concern about what he called “unwillingness of MPD under the supervision of Chief Pelletier to provide any updates regarding the New Year’s fireworks incident damaging the Galloway’s property when Lt. Vaituulala was present, and concerns about whether the above has led to overall loss of confidence in his ability to lead the department at this time.”

Tam said that since the Oct. 7, 2026 meeting, “I feel the comments made Pelletier at his Oct. 9, 2026 press conference do not support reinstating Chief Pelletier and further support our decision to place him on leave to protect the investigation. For example, Pelletier made a statement that the commission was influenced by the mayor. Speaking for myself, as chair, I was not influenced by the mayor,” he said.

Chief’s attorney argues that a hearing is in order

Attorney Eric Seitz. PC: Wendy Osher (11.18.26)

Pelletier’s attorney argued that procedure would have required a hearing before placing his client on leave with pay.

“We will cooperate in any investigation you want. You have every right to investigate the chief as part of your oversight for any and everything that your think is appropriate, but you can’t suspend him before you at least give him a hearing,” said Pelletier’s attorney during Wednesday’s meeting. “And so, all I’m asking of you is you reinstate him—That we have a discussion about the terms and conditions… and that we come to some agreement, and then I won’t have to sue you.”

“You have to understand—You should know what the legal situation is and what the County Charter requires of you. It’s clear in black and white. You have to have a contested hearing before you can take any disciplinary action. And if you don’t reinstate him knowing that, it will be malicious,” said Seitz.

He warned: “All of you will be individually liable and responsible. And so we will sue you—not just the county. We will have to sue all of you individually.”

He said every effort should be made to avoid litigation. “We’re more than happy to sit down and talk with you, but we have to have that discussion.”

“I was extremely appalled today listening to the public statements. You had a number of people, very knowledgeable come forward and testify in support of the chief, about all of the things that he has accomplished. But the people who got up and opposed it, they really didn’t have anything specific to say,” said Seitz who questioned the quality of what was presented, accusing opponents of spreading “horrible rhetoric.”

The next regular meeting of the Maui Police Commission is scheduled for Dec. 16, 2026 at 10 a.m.

*A full report on the legal ramifications, thoughts on where the investigation goes from here and what to expect in the coming months will be covered in depth by the Hawaiʻi Journalism Initiative. Check back for more.

ADVERTISEMENT
Wendy Osher
Wendy Osher leads the Maui Now news team. She is also the news voice of parent company, Pacific Media Group, having served more than 20 years as News Director for the company’s six Maui radio stations.
Read Full Bio
ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsored Content

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Stay in-the-know with daily or weekly
headlines delivered straight to your inbox.
Cancel
×

Comments

This comments section is a public community forum for the purpose of free expression. Although Maui Now encourages respectful communication only, some content may be considered offensive. Please view at your own discretion. View Comments