
The Maui County Council’s Housing and Land Use Committee voted Wednesday to recommend full Council approval of two bills for the EC Pāʻia Town project, a proposed 170-unit, mixed-use development on roughly 40 acres near Pāʻia town. The committee voted 8-0 for Bill 167 (2026), a community plan amendment, and 6-2 for Bill 168 (2026), a conditional change in zoning.
Council Members Tamara Paltin and Gabe Johnson voted no on Bill 168. Council Member Keani Rawlins-Fernandez was absent and excused for both votes. Committee Chair Nohelani Uʻu-Hodgins introduced the resolution that sent the project to the Maui Planning Commission. She voted yes.
In September, the Maui Planning Commission recommended the rezoning 5-3 and voted unanimously for the community plan amendment. The Council had earlier referred the project to the commission through Resolution 26-84.
Paltin said she has concerns about water availability and voted no to challenge the public to turn out for a public hearing. She noted that an applicant-initiated community plan amendment would trigger an environmental assessment or environmental impact statement. “I’m open to changing my mind,” she said.
Johnson said he wants a community meeting held in Pāʻia after working hours and plans to ask colleagues to request a public hearing when the bills reach the full Council. Three council members must request one.
The committee adopted the amendments to Bill 168 without dissent among members voting. They add to conditions the Council attached in June and the Planning Commission recommended in September:
The committee also amended the bill’s effective date. The ordinance will take effect when the state Land Use Commission votes to approve a district boundary amendment from agricultural to urban, within 10 years. The Department of Planning director may approve extensions.
Planning Director Jacky Takakura said the department supports the project.
“It brings much needed housing in a way that keeps with the character of Pāʻia Town,” she said.
Takakura said she did not think the department could enforce Condition 6, but Chipchase said it would run with the land as a deed restriction.
Chipchase said the property is owned by Sam Hirbod through an LLC and not by a large corporation. Sixty of the 170 homes would be income-restricted: 34 workforce rentals affordable in perpetuity and 26 for-sale gap-group homes, according to exchanges between the developers and council members. The remaining roughly 110 homes would be market-priced.
The project also includes a roughly 200-stall public parking lot, free for Maui County residents under a Planning Commission condition. It includes a medical clinic and urgent care, neighborhood commercial space, and a relocated, two-way Pāʻia bypass.
Chipchase said state law does not require environmental review for a Council-initiated community plan amendment. The project must still go through Land Use Commission review, environmental review and a special management area permit, a process he estimated at five to eight years before the project has an approved subdivision.
Takakura said the Council-initiated process also differs in its public-notice and application requirements. Although the department received an application for this project, some information arrived after agency review, she said.
On water, Chipchase said the county Department of Water Supply has described its system as close to capacity. A Department of Planning staff report cites an Aug. 14 letter from Water Supply Director John Stufflebean. The letter says projected demand on the Central Maui system is 98% to 100% of its maximum reliable capacity, leaving no additional source capacity for new or expanded service.
Chipchase said the developer would look to county water first if it becomes available, possibly in five to eight years. Otherwise, he said, it would use a skimming well on the property, possibly with a water exchange with neighboring landowner Mahi Pono. He estimated potable demand at 75,000 gallons a day.
Paltin questioned how the developer’s estimate compared with the Department of Water Supply’s figures. Chipchase said the calculations treated nonpotable demand differently. Harold Edwards of ITC, a project consultant, said the housing mix also had changed since the department’s review, with more single-family homes increasing potable demand. Edwards said the developer’s combined estimate for potable and nonpotable water was higher than the county’s.
Takakura said water details would need to be resolved during later permitting and should not stop the project at this preliminary stage.
Opponents said the project needs environmental review before approval. Rob Bence asked the committee to “defer this to the next Council or deny this.” Lauren Blickley cited 235 petition signatures against the project and asked for owner-occupancy requirements on single-family homes. Lucienne de Naie said a community plan amendment should trigger state environmental review.
Supporters pointed to the shortage of homes for local families. CJ Elizares said he and his family “do not qualify for affordable workforce housing because my household makes too much.”
Sam Kim, a government relations representative for the Hawaiʻi Regional Council of Carpenters, cited the 2024 Hawaii Housing Planning Study, saying it projected a need for nearly 15,000 more homes in Maui County by 2027.
Several committee members explained their votes before the roll call.
Council Member Tom Cook, who voted yes, said projects like this take years of planning and a large investment from the developer. “Very, very special people” take them on, he said, “especially someone that’s not a major corporation.”
The community needs to be more supportive of such projects, he said. There will be no healthy growth “if we don’t start building communities.”
Cook also said concerns about water availability are hypocritical. He said that litigation and a consent decree over East Maui water have kept the region from developing water for 20 years and that some of the people who brought those cases now cite the lack of water.
“You can’t build a community with 732 restrictions,” he said.
Council Member Shane Sinenci said he supported the bill in committee to gain potential “additional evacuation routes” out of Pāʻia town, which the developer described as being through the top of the property and across Mahi Pono land to Firebreak Road. Sinenci reserved his final position for second reading, when he said he wants to see what the community wants.
Council Vice Chair Yuki Lei Sugimura praised the developer’s team.
“I think this is a development project that we’re going to see over time that they are good for their word, and they believe in the strength of the community,” she said.
Paltin said she would vote yes on Bill 167. She cited the project’s adherence to the Maui Island Plan growth boundary, the choice of ʻĀina Archaeology and the developer’s willingness to entertain her conditions.
On Bill 168, she said she wants to hear from residents. “I would love to see how much people want it,” she said. She also asked that the Planning Commission send the Council its minutes on the item being heard, saying the 885-page packet could be about 600 pages if it left out unrelated commission items.
Uʻu-Hodgins said during her closing comments that she was speaking in two roles, as “a council member that sits in this position” and as someone from Pāʻia. The community there now is “arguably” not the one she grew up in, she said, describing the town as a “field of nightmares” because homes were not built there and people came anyway.
Uʻu-Hodgins said Pāʻia’s population has fallen from about 10,000 when her grandmother was in high school to about 2,500, and that a majority of current residents are not originally from Pāʻia.
She said she supported the project in committee and will do so when it reaches the full Council. Her goal is to make Pāʻia local again, she said. Market-rate homes are not luxury homes, she added. By her account, listings she found online the night before ranged from studios at the low end to homes over $1 million, then homes about $1.5 million to $1.8 million, and oceanfront homes of $4 million to $10 million.
Much of the traffic in Pāʻia comes from Haʻikū residents and visitors rather than Pāʻia residents, she said. A two-way bypass would be “huge,” she added.
The committee recommended both bills for first reading by the full Council, which is expected to take up the measures Dec. 9 if the project’s unilateral agreement is ready in time. The committee vote followed an all-day meeting that included roughly an hour and a half of testimony from a dozen members of the public.
The Council’s last meeting for this year is scheduled for Dec. 23.