Breaking News Alerts

We'd like to send you alerts when breaking news happens. Hide this Message

Press "Allow" to Activate

Search
Aloha, !
My Profile | Logout
Aloha, Guest!
Login | Register
  • News Topics
    • Front Page
    • Maui News
    • 2022 Election
    • Business
    • Food & Dining
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Real Estate
    • Crime Statistics
    • Local Sports
  • Weather & Surf
    • Weather Forecast
    • Surf Report
  • Lifestyle & Culture
    • Maui Arts & Entertainment
    • Food and Dining
    • On the Menu
    • Real Estate
    • Obituaries
  • Opinion
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Maui Discussion
    • Reader Survey
  • Events Calendar
    • Upcoming Maui Events
    • Map of Events
    • Post an Event
  • Job Listings
    • Maui Jobs
    • Recent Job Listings
    • Job Alerts
    • Post a Job
  • Special Sections
    • IMUA Discovery Garden
    • Medical Minute
  • Video
    • Latest Maui Videos
  • × Close Menu
  • About Maui Now
  • Newsletter
  • Contact Information
  • Get the App
  • Advertising
  • Meet the Team
Choose Your Island:
  • Kauai
  • Maui
  • Big Island
Copyright © 2023 Pacific Media Group
All Rights Reserved

Privacy Policy | About Our Ads

Maui Now
Search
Aloha, !
My Profile | Logout
Aloha, Guest!
Login | Register
    Maui Now
  • Sections
  • Maui News
  • Business
  • Weather
  • Entertainment
  • Election
  • Real Estate
  • Jobs
  • Obituaries
  • Opinion

Real Estate

Large Nāpili house should not have gotten green light, Maui council member says

By Kehaulani Cerizo
May 25, 2022, 6:00 AM HST
* Updated May 25, 1:01 PM
Play
Listen to this Article
4 minutes
Loading Audio... Article will play after ad...
Playing in :00
A
A
A

County of Maui photo.
The controversial Greg Brown house in Napili is shown on March 24, 2022. PC: Kehaulani Cerizo

In the latest chapter for a controversial house that towers over other homes in Nāpili, Maui County Council Member Tamara Paltin said her investigation shows the developer shouldn’t have gotten a key exemption that allowed construction to bypass public input.  

The unfinished, eight-bedroom home at 5385 Lower Honoapiʻilani Road, initially designed with rooftop and floor-level pools, came under fire last year when it climbed toward 45 feet tall. 

Residents questioned how the county signed off on the plans without public input.  The county’s Planning and Public Works departments, not the council, had jurisdiction over the approvals and permits.

On Tuesday, Paltin, whose residency seat covers West Maui, pointed to an email where the developer told the county Planning Department that the house would be used as a short-term vacation rental.  

That’s one reason why the structure shouldn’t have received a Special Management Area exemption, she said during the council Government Relations, Ethics and Transparency committee meeting. 

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW AD
ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW AD

“The plot seems to thicken here,” committee Chairman Mike Molina said.  

Meanwhile, community members who oppose the development are showing no sign of backing down. 

“I don’t have to know all the rules or whatever to know that it’s just not right,” longtime Lahaina resident Cheryl Hotta testified Tuesday. “If he gets away with this, there are a lot of other developers that are going to follow suit and just keep destroying our natural environment.” 

Mark Deakos, a West Maui resident for 25 years, said the home is “quite the monstrosity,” adding that he hopes it doesn’t set a precedent for future houses.  

Nāpili resident Junya Nakoa, who was tapped as a council resource, said that officials are shifting blame in a situation that was wrong from the start. 

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW AD

“You guys give one SMA exception and they screwed up,” he said. “So someone (should) get lickins or the buggah get fired or permits withdrawn, pull that buggah, I don’t know what kind of language you want to put it in, but it’s wrong.” 

Community members have pushed for stop-work orders, repealing permits, criminal investigations and more. Some even threatened the county and the council with legal action. 

However, owner and developer Greg Brown has maintained that his home complies with county rules.  

Due to outdated county zoning code, buildings in the Nāpili district were allowed to be two stories tall — but no height was specified. Brown’s structure triggered fast legislation last year that now prevents future area buildings from being more than 30 feet in height. 

Additionally, the district allowed for short-term rentals and other hotel uses without permits that are required in other areas.  

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW AD

Despite repeated questioning, the Planning Department also has said it followed proper guidelines. 

Plans for the home showed that it was less than 7,500 square feet, which was the basis for the SMA exemption. Also, Planning Director Michele McLean has said that Brown told the department the structure would be used as a single-family residence. 

The project in 2019 gained a Special Management Area permit exemption, which does not involve a public notice or a public hearing like a major SMA would require.

Paltin on Tuesday asked McLean for an email showing the home would be used as a single-family residence.

“The staff planner who had made those inquiries could not find that email,” McLean responded. “And in fact found an email to the contrary.” 

“Nonetheless we wrote to the applicant in March of 2021, informing him that our approvals were based on the structure being used as a second home or for long-term residency and our issuance of the exemption was based on it being used for long-term occupancy or second home — and that short-term rentals will not be allowed,” she added. “And he has not, the applicant, the owner, has not appealed the decision — so that decision stands.” 

In 2018 emails with county planner Jim Buika, Brown and Tom Schnell of PBR Hawaii, Buika asks the two if the structure is a “house, home, apartment or short-term rental,” county documents show. 

“You state it is home/single-family residence but the design does not reflect this,” Buika wrote Aug. 10, 2018.  

Brown on Sept. 19, 2018, responded that it is not a hotel; “it is a residential home that I have designed for my family that I can legally vacation rent on hotel property. I had brought the plans in and met with Anne to confirm all of this before I submitted it.” 

“I am a thirty year resident of Hawaii with five children and thus the reason for the large home along with a better legal rental potential,” he added. 

Now, Maui County Council is considering whether to pursue an outside investigation that would sift through what happened and provide recommendations on where to go from here.  

Molina on Tuesday deferred the item, saying it will be resumed early next month. 

“There is a lot more questions to be answered and upon the revelation of member Paltin’s investigation, certainly I guess is worthy of a conversation potentially having outside eyes look at this whole matter,” Molina said. “The chair wants to bring closure to this issue, the Nāpili community has certainly expressed their concerns with this matter.”

Kehaulani Cerizo
Kehaulani Cerizo was born and raised on Maui and worked for nearly 15 years as a news reporter, copy editor and features editor at daily newspapers. She earned awards at The Maui News in Wailuku and at Today’s Local News in San Diego.
Read Full Bio
Maui Jobs View All Jobs Chevron Forward

Kā‘anapali Beach Hotel
Beach/Sales Alakaʻi (agent) - Hybrid | $1,000 Sign On Bonus
West Maui · 3 weeks ago
Andaz Beach Crew Maui
Beach Attendant and Ocean Sports
South Maui · 6 days ago
Maui Kamaole
Landscaping grounds keeper
South Maui · 3 hours ago

Valley Isle Home Care
Care Team Member
Central Maui · 3 weeks ago
Looking for locally based talent?
Post a Job Listing

Sponsored Content

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Stay in-the-know with daily or weekly
headlines delivered straight to your inbox.
Cancel
×

Related Articles

  • Council committee recommends that Maui County…
    June 28, 2022
  • How have galaxies flowed across 700 million light…
    February 3, 2022
  • County Issues Stop Work Order for Construction of…
    December 16, 2021
  • The Green concert on Maui is sold out, guests should…
    September 23, 2022
  • Should Hawaiʻi visitors pay a $50 per year green…
    March 2, 2023
  • Green: Most mandates may be lifted soon; county…
    February 16, 2022
Make the most of your Maui vacation with these top-rated activities: Maui Top 20: Maui Visitor & Tourism Information

Comments

This comments section is a public community forum for the purpose of free expression. Although Maui Now encourages respectful communication only, some content may be considered offensive. Please view at your own discretion. View Comments
View All Events: List Circle List Map
UPCOMING FEATURED EVENTS:
Add Post an Event More Events Chevron Forward
Trending Now
1Striking Upw Workers Reject Latest Contract Offer From Maui Health 2Maui Land Pineapple Announces Leadership Transition 3Mayor Richard Bissen Jr Identifies Priorities In His First State Of The County Address 4Shark Warning Signs Removed After Apparent Shark Bite Incident On Hawaiʻi Island 5The Adventure Park On Maui Re Opens With New Look And Management 6Sba Announces Hawaiʻis 2023 Top Small Business Winners
Arrow UpBack to Top
  • Maui News
  • Maui Business
  • Weather
  • Entertainment
  • Maui Surf
  • Maui Sports
  • COVID-19 Updates
  • Crime Statistics
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Maui Activities
  • Maui Discussion
  • Food and Dining
  • Real Estate
  • Events
  • What’s Open
  • Maui Jobs
  • About Maui Now
  • Contact Information
  • About Our Ads
  • App
  • Newsletter
  • Terms of Service

Copyright © 2023. Pacific Media Group.
All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | About Our Ads

Facebook YouTube Twitter Instagram