Hawai'i Journalism InitiativeInvestigation against Maui Police Chief Pelletier widens as his attorney threatens lawsuit

KAHULUI — When the lawyer for Maui Police Chief John Pelletier stepped up to the podium after several hours of heated public debate on Wednesday, he issued the Maui Police Commission an ultimatum — reinstate the embattled chief or face a lawsuit.
“You have every right to investigate the chief as part of your oversight for any and everything you think is appropriate,” Seitz said. “But you can’t suspend him before you at least give him a hearing. And so all I’m asking of you is you reinstate him, that we have a discussion about the terms and conditions for doing that, and we come to some agreement, and then I won’t have to sue you.”
Not only did the commission vote 6-1 to keep Pelletier on paid leave, but they also decided to expand their investigation of him to include statements he made at a press conference on Oct. 9 criticizing the commission and alleging two criminal investigations against Mayor Richard Bissen.
The decision came ofter more than two dozen supporters and detractors of Pelletier testified for roughly four hours on whether the Maui Police Department chief should remain on leave or be reinstated.

Pelletier has been sidelined since Oct. 7, when the Police Commission voted unanimously to place him on leave while it conducted an investigation of the chief’s oversight of the Maui Police Department’s Criminal Intelligence Unit. Lt. Michael Vaituulala, the head of the unit, was arrested in August on federal bribery charges for allegedly protecting drug traffickers, organizers of chicken fights and importers of illegal fireworks.
Seitz, who spoke near the end of the almost seven-hour meeting on Wednesday, argued that the commission didn’t follow proper procedures when they placed him on leave because they discussed the decision during executive session and didn’t specify the evidence or allegations against him. Seitz said that under the Maui County Charter, Pelletier should have had a hearing before he was placed on leave.
He told reporters afterwards he could file a lawsuit on Pelletier’s behalf as early as next week.
Chair Frank Tam defended the commission’s decision on Wednesday, saying they saw “a need to protect the integrity of the investigation in the face of serious federal criminal corruption charges against the head of the CIU, when the CIU directly reported to the chief.”
At the Oct. 9 news conference, which was held in Honolulu where Seitz is based, Pelletier claimed the commissioners had been pressured by Bissen and that their decision was “a direct result of criminal investigations involving the mayor and his office.”
Pelletier said one investigation was related to a whistleblower lawsuit filed against Bissen by former chief of staff Leo Caires, who alleges he was wrongfully terminated for reporting fraudulent activities by county officials. Pelletier said the other investigation involved “a felonious crime, and the mayor is the suspect,” but he provided no details.
Both Tam and Bissen have denied the mayor tried to influence the commission’s decision, and Prosecuting Attorney Andrew Martin also issued a statement denying claims that the mayor was under investigation, which the commission also planned to take into account.
“I feel the comments Pelletier made in his October 9th press conference do not support reinstating Pelletier and further support our decision to put him on leave to protect the investigation,” Tam said.
Seitz walked back some of Pelletier’s claims on Wednesday while speaking with reporters after the meeting. While Seitz said they were aware of a federal or state investigation into the mayor, “I don’t know who’s being investigated or what the scope of it is.” He also said he did not know what felony charge the mayor was allegedly facing because “I have not analyzed or evaluated it, I’ve just read it (the civil complaint).”
“I just know what the subject matters are, that’s all,” he said. “But they could give rise to criminal investigations and criminal charges. So there’s not a felony specified in there, but it could lead to a felony charge.”

When asked why Pelletier referenced a felony if there was not one, Seitz said, “because in our opinion, what’s alleged in the Leo Caires lawsuit could constitute very serious crimes. Felonies, yes. It could. That just depends on where those investigations are going. I don’t know because nobody’s going to tell us.”
Tam said the commission will be hiring a separate investigator to look into Pelletier’s comments at the news conference.
The commission already has hired Littler Mendelson, a labor and employment law firm with offices in Honolulu, to conduct the investigation into Pelletier’s oversight of the Criminal Intelligence Unit, which is expected to take six months. Tam told reporters after the meeting that the contract with the law firm could cost more than $50,000.
Seitz told the commission that Pelletier could remain on the job while the investigation was being conducted, and that the commission could take precautions such as putting a trusted person in charge of preserving important records for investigation and not allowing the chief to access them.
Tam said after the meeting that Seitz “would have to clarify exactly what those steps would be.” However, during the meeting he expressed concerns about Pelletier remaining on the job during the investigation and didn’t want any officers or employees to “feel any pressure” when questioned about the chief’s supervisory approach.
He said that Seitz was correct about the charter process for removing the chief “if there’s allegations against the chief.”
“But we’re not alleging that the chief did anything,” Tam said. “All we’re saying is that it would be in the best interest of the investigation for him not to remain in place.”
Commissioners also wanted to question Pelletier, but Seitz said they would respond to the commission’s questions in writing. Pelletier declined to comment after the meeting, deferring to his attorney.
Across hours of testimony, Pelletier received praise from some current officers and community members who said he was fighting corruption in a department plagued by previous scandals and making improvements to police technology and officers’ well-being.
But he also was criticized by some retired officers and other residents who raised issues over his leadership and treatment of officers that led to gender discrimination and harassment complaints and said he should held accountable.

Stacey Moniz, former chair of the Maui Police Commission, pointed out that Pelletier had received positive performance evaluations and made strides in the department that included naming MPD’s first woman assistant chief of police. She said the arrest of Vaituulala, rather than a sign of corruption higher up, could be “evidence that the culture is changing.”
“What if the chief’s response is part of the accountability that we hired him to establish?” she said. “And my question really is, where is due process? How is it that the commission is holding the chief responsible for the actions of Lt. Vaituulala? … There’s never been any evidence of any wrongdoing on behalf of the chief. He’s not been charged with anything.”
But Dean Rickard, a 34-year MPD veteran who retired as deputy chief in December 2021 when Pelletier took over, said the commission’s decision to conduct an independent investigation was the right call, and that the community “should feel assured that issues tied to public safety and the use of official power receive serious attention.”
“The credibility of the process depends on its independence and integrity,” Rickard said. “At the same time, accountability and fairness must go hand in hand. No individual should be above accountability because of rank, position or title. Equally important, no person should be judged before facts are collected and assessed to a full, impartial conclusion.”

Some testifiers also questioned the commission’s ability to be impartial, given that some members donated to the mayor’s 2022 and 2026 campaigns, including Joseph Arias, Donald Cameron, Shackley Raffetto and Lahela Aiwohi, the lone vote against the decision to deny Pelletier’s reinstatement.
“The issue is not whether actual bias exists,” said Chuck Spence, co-chair of the Multi-Cultural Advisory Counsel created by Pelletier. “The issue is whether the public can have confidence that the decision-making process is free from the appearance of bias.”
The previous commission under Moniz also faced a choice of whether to place Pelletier on leave in March 2025 when he was accused of posing as a sheriff in a lawsuit filed by a woman who reported being raped by rapper Sean “Diddy” Combs. At the time, Bissen recommended Pelletier be placed on leave. While the mayor does not have the authority to remove the chief, the charter allows him to have “a voice but no vote” in board and commission proceedings. The commission voted unanimously to keep Pelletier on the job, and the lawsuit was eventually dismissed.
Supporters of Pelletier pointed to the incident as proof of Bissen’s bias against Pelletier as well as the fact that Bissen had backed a different candidate for police chief in 2021.
Victor Ramos, one of the five finalists at the time, attended the commission meeting and told the Hawai‘i Journalism Initiative that Bissen had written letters of recommendation for him and fellow finalist Everett Ferreira.
Ramos, a 33-year MPD veteran who retired as assistant chief in December 2021, said he had known Bissen for 40 years. At the time, Bissen was still a 2nd Circuit Court judge and hadn’t yet declared his candidacy.
“At the time I asked him, I didn’t even know he was going to run for mayor,” Ramos said. “So that had nothing to do with it. It was just someone looking for a reference from an outstanding person in the community.”
Ramos said the notion that Bissen’s support for him meant he opposed Pelletier “has no merit whatsoever.”

Bissen was unavailable for an interview Wednesday night because he was at a community meeting, but Laksmi Abraham, director of communications and government affairs, said that support for one candidate “does not equate to opposition to another.” She said that Bissen publicly committed to collaborating with the chief before he took office.
“Throughout his administration, the Mayor has demonstrated that commitment through substantial investments in police personnel, recruitment and retention, equipment, technology and operational resources, including numerous initiatives advanced by Chief Pelletier himself,” Abraham said.
In response to concerns over some commissioners’ political support for Bissen, Abraham said, “to suggest that a campaign contribution alone establishes bias or improper influence is unfounded.”
“Supporting a candidate for public office does not, in itself, compromise an individual’s ability to exercise independent judgment or impartially fulfill their responsibilities as a commissioner,” she said. “As previously stated, Mayor Bissen did not influence the Police Commission’s decision to place Chief Pelletier on administrative leave.”


