Maui County committees advance nepotism rules and legislative travel policy bill

A Maui County Council committee voted Tuesday to recommend countywide nepotism rules that would bar officials and employees, including council members, the mayor and department heads, from hiring or supervising relatives.
The bill aims to ensure that hiring, supervision and employment decisions are based on merit, qualifications, ability and equal opportunity, rather than family relationships or favoritism.
The Government Relations, Ethics and Transparency Committee’s vote was 8-0, with Council Member Shane Sinenci absent and excused. The committee, chaired by Council Member Kauanoe Batangan, recommended that the full Council pass Bill 99 (2026), Committee Draft 1, on first reading.
Earlier the same day, the Budget, Finance and Economic Development Committee, chaired by Council Member Yuki Lei Sugimura, recommended that the full Council pass Bill 140 (2026). That measure authorizes the director of Council Services and the County Clerk to establish written travel policies for council members and specified legislative-branch officers and employees, subject to Council chair approval and certain requirements. The committee vote was 9-0.
Nepotism rules
Bill 99 would add a nepotism section to Chapter 2.56 of the Maui County Code. Council Chair Alice Lee introduced it at the mayor’s request. The chapter covers ordinances and the county’s administrative framework for the Maui County Code of Ethics. The chapter sets ethical standards for county officials, employees and candidates to preserve public trust in local government. It works alongside Article 10 of the Maui County Charter.
The bill bars covered workers from hiring, promoting, firing or supervising a relative or household member in their agency. It also bars them from taking part in related interviews or discussions, and from awarding contracts to businesses in which a relative or household member is an executive officer or substantial owner. Relatives include parents, grandparents, children, siblings, spouses, in-laws, first cousins and people considered immediate family through the Hawaiian hānai custom.

Lauren Akitake, executive director and legal counsel of the Board of Ethics, said the bill does not bar relatives from working for Maui County. The legislation targets hiring, supervision, evaluation and discipline, and that the county auditor’s Spire audit highlighted that Maui County is one of two Hawaiʻi jurisdictions without a countywide policy, she said.
“Across government, non-profit organizations, and private industry, anti-nepotism policies are widely recognized as a best practice because they promote fairness, reduce favoritism, and strengthen public confidence,” she said. “The underlying principle of this proposal is straightforward. Employment decisions should be made and should be seen and appear to be made based on merit rather than family relationships.”
“This ordinance is not about the past. It’s about establishing consistent standards and deciding what kind of organization we want to be going forward,” Akitake said.
Deputy Corporation Counsel Caleb Rowe responded to a question whether the bill’s nepotism prohibitions would apply to council members. He told the committee that, as written, the bill’s prohibitions apply to employees, a term that excludes officers under the County Code, including elected officials, the mayor and department heads. He suggested expanding the definition to “officer or employee,” which would include elected officials. The committee agreed, voting 8-0 with Sinenci absent, to expand the definition.
Council Member Keani Rawlins-Fernandez suggested and the committee agreed to start the law Jan. 4, 2027, rather than Jan. 1.
The amended committee draft version also includes Batangan’s proposal to require the Board of Ethics to write administrative rules for “good cause” waivers. The bill lets the board waive the rules for an employee or agency that cannot comply, including because of a demonstrated lack of qualified personnel or applicants.
Council Member Tom Cook said he supports the intent of the bill but worried about council offices. He disclosed that he has a daughter working for him and had a son who worked for him six months previously.
“It’s a very intimate job being an [executive assistant] for a council member, and it’s not just nine to five, and it’s . . . That’s all I can say,” he said, but later added that “for me personally, I would not feel comfortable being limited.”
Akitake said the board favors no blanket exemptions from anti-nepotism standards for any county department or office, and Batangan said he saw no appetite for a motion to exempt the Council.
She pointing out that the Hawaiʻi State Ethics Commission has a “good cause exception,” which includes a standard application form. An example of that form is on Page 37 of a set of informational documents from the Board of Ethics.
“A good cause exception would provide a transparent case-by-case process for the board to consider unique circumstances where strict application of the ordinance would not further its purpose or would produce a result contrary to the public interest,” Akitake said.
Council Member Gabe Johnson asked about exempting Lānaʻi. Akitake pointed to the waiver process and said the board would call special meetings if needed.
A Nov. 16 memo from Akitake’s office cites the State Ethics Commission waivers, including one letting Hāna High & Elementary School hire a principal’s son as an emergency-hire teacher.
Akitake said her office intends to delay enforcement six months so departments can adjust reporting lines or seek waivers.
“During the transition period, departments will review existing employment relationships and, where possible, restructure reporting relationships or reallocate responsibilities to eliminate prohibited circumstances,” the memo says. “The transition period is intended to provide an opportunity to achieve compliance, not to automatically exempt existing employment relationships from the ordinance.”
Akitake’s memo describes the deferral as applying only to existing employment relationships. The bill does not include the delay; Batangan asked staff to note the enforcement date in the committee report. Akitake also said violations carry a $1,000 fine each.
Legislative travel
Bill 140 would authorize the director of Council Services and the county clerk to draft travel policies for council members, their staff and employees of both offices, subject to the approval of the Council chair. The rules would require advance approval of expenses, limit reimbursement to reasonable and necessary costs, prohibit paying for personal travel or alcohol, and set per diem allowances for particular circumstances at or above comparable rates for other Hawaiʻi government workers.
Director of Council Services David Raatz said the Finance Department’s June 15 travel policies prompted the bill. He said federal General Services Administration rates are higher than the per diem now in the code, notably for inter-island trips. No new legislative policy is drafted, he said, and he did not expect major changes beyond per diem. No one testified.
Rawlins-Fernandez won a 9-0 amendment requiring the chair to approve policies after consultation with council members. “I’m just asking for communication and dialogue like we’re doing now,” Rawlins-Fernandez said.
What’s next?
Bill 99 and Bill 140 are expected to be on the full Council’s Dec. 9 agenda for first reading. Passage on second reading is required before the measures move on to the desk of Mayor Richard Bissen.












