Maui County Council advances Haʻikū fire station land use bills, 6-2, over ancestral land objections

The Maui County Council approved on first reading Friday three land use bills for a long-awaited fire station in Haʻikū. The 6-2 vote came over objections from two council members and from Native Hawaiian testifiers who maintain the site is their ancestral land.
The Council also advanced two ethics bills: One setting a $1,000 administrative fine for ethics violations and extending the amount of time for the Board of Ethics to retain jurisdiction over alleged violations; and another to set lobbyist regulations and establish a maximum $5,000 administrative fine for knowing violations.
Regarding the Haʻikū fire station project, Bills 89, 90 and 91 (2026), Committee Draft 1, would clear the way for the station on 6.097 acres of a 27.9-acre county-owned parcel in Hāmākualoa. They would reclassify the land from state agricultural to rural, amend the Pāʻia-Haʻikū Community Plan from agriculture to public/quasi-public and change county zoning from agricultural to public/quasi-public.
The Council adopted Housing and Land Use Committee Report 26-75 to advance the measures, which need a second and final reading before moving on to Mayor Richard Bissen for final action.
Council Members Nohelani Uʻu-Hodgins, Tom Cook, Tamara Paltin, Shane Sinenci, Vice Chair Yuki Lei Sugimura and Council Chair Alice Lee voted in favor. Keani Rawlins-Fernandez and Gabe Johnson voted no. Kauanoe Batangan recused himself and abstained, citing a Charter conflict because he worked on the project as a land use planner for consultant Munekiyo Hiraga before joining the Council.
“Ancestral ʻāina”
Rawlins-Fernandez said she would stand by her committee vote against the bills. “None of the folks who opposed this fire station is opposed to a fire station in the area. It’s the ancestral ʻāina of folks who have testified,” she said.

Rawlins-Fernandez said she supports the fire department and a station in the area, and that she agreed with a testifier that a station need not come at the expense of severing ʻohana from their ancestral ʻāina. She said she found it hard to vote to take ancestral ʻāina from others on the same day the Council celebrated the return of ancestral ʻāina to the people of Molokaʻi.
Earlier in the meeting, the Council approved, 8-1, bills setting aside $30 million for Molokaʻi land acquisitions. Sugimura cast the lone dissenting vote, citing her belief that more public information and transparency was needed before the Council took action.
Earlier in the meeting, the Council gave final approval, 8-1, to Bills 150 and 151 (2026). Bill 150 adds $30 million to the fiscal 2027 budget for Molokaʻi land acquisitions, and Bill 151 allows the use of general obligation bonds for the purchases. Sugimura cast the lone dissenting vote, saying more public information and transparency were needed before the Council committed the money.
Johnson said he supports fire stations “in the proper place,” but that a station should not end up “igniting anger within our community.”
Sinenci, who voted “aye, with reservations” in committee, said he could support using 6 acres of the larger parcel for the fire station. He urged county archaeologists to work closely with the State Historic Preservation Division to protect cultural sites around the 6 acres, and he backed using the rest of the parcel for agriculture and cultural purposes.
Public testimony
Tanner Mosher, a Maui firefighter and Maui Division chair of the Hawaii Fire Fighters Association, told the Council the closest help for Haʻikū families is in Pāʻia, about six miles away, with Makawao about eight.
“The families of Haʻikū have waited 17 years for a station,” he said.
Capt. Nohea Williams, an 18-year Maui Fire Department firefighter assigned to Ladder 3 in Lahaina, submitted written testimony in support.
“Every firefighter in this county knows that minutes save lives,” he wrote. “When we are called to someone who is unresponsive and not breathing, the clock did not start when the tones dropped. It started before that. Everything we carry, all the training, all the equipment, only matters if we are standing there in time to use it. There is no tool on that apparatus that gives back the minutes we spent driving. On a house fire, those same minutes can be the difference between saving someone, or their home, and losing them.”
A single call to Keʻanae takes the Pāʻia station out of its own district for at least two hours, there and back, he said. “A station there is one more crew that can be sent anywhere on this island on the worst day.”
He cited the Hawaii Fire Fighters Association’s mapping, saying fewer than a third of Maui County residents live within four minutes of a fire station.
Zhantell Lindo, the wife of a 30-year firefighter, also testified in support, saying more than 70% of rural calls are medical.
Lucienne de Naie thanked the Council for moving the project forward.

Kanealii Williams, who has contested the county’s title to the land, testified that the State Historic Preservation Division registered Native Hawaiian burials on the property after a Sept. 11 site visit and documented damage to a historic feature there. He alleged the county demolished a rock wall and mound during work in 2023, contrary to preservation requirements.
Kahala Johnson, citing the public trust doctrine and Article XI of the state Constitution, said public safety does not automatically outweigh the public trust.
“We can protect our communities from fires and emergencies while honoring kanaka kuleana to land,” he said. He said he served a complaint and summons on Corporation Counsel Victoria Takayesu Friday morning, before the meeting.
Lala Johnson, a Native Hawaiian with family ties to Hāmākualoa, urged the Council to defer the vote. She said the complaint was filed Nov. 10 in the 2nd Circuit’s Environmental Court.
County attorneys have said the county holds clear title, citing a title insurance policy.
When given an opportunity Monday to respond to Williams’ allegation or the complaint in 2nd Circuit Court, the Maui County Communications Office declined to respond to Williams’ allegation that the county destroyed archaeological features in 2023. The office reported that, according to the Department of the Corporation Counsel, the County does not comment on pending litigation.
Archaeological commitments
Before the vote, Paltin read into the record commitments she said would be provided in writing. She said the Department of ʻŌiwi Resources would provide all archaeological services directed by the State Historic Preservation Division. These include a 100% archaeological inventory survey of the newly identified utility trench area, one archaeological monitor per piece of ground-altering equipment in that area, an onsite cultural monitor, and a final report for division review and comment. She said the fire chief had committed to the measures.
Earlier in the meeting, the Council filed Paltin’s proposed amendment to Bill 91 (County Communication 26-29), with Rawlins-Fernandez excused. Paltin said the chief had agreed to the commitments in writing without a formal condition, mainly because a condition would delay the unilateral agreement timeframe.
Uʻu-Hodgins, who chairs the Housing and Land Use Committee, said the committee also supported conditions to protect adjacent farming and require Right to Farm Act notices. It also supported requiring part of the property not used for the station to go toward subsistence agriculture pilot projects.
The Maui Planning Commission recommended approval of the bills Jan. 27. The county bought the property in 2007.
Ethics bill move forward
The Council also gave final approval Friday to Bill 55 (2026), voting 9-0 on second and final reading with no discussion.
The bill sets an administrative fine of up to $1,000 for each violation of the ethics article of the Maui County Charter or of Chapter 2.56 of the Maui County Code. It also lets the Board of Ethics keep jurisdiction over alleged violations by any person, including current and former officers and employees, for six years after the violation, up from one year.
If fraud or another device concealed a violation, the six years would start when it was discovered or reasonably should have been discovered.
Board of Ethics Executive Director and Legal Counsel Lauren Akitake testified in support, saying the board can lose the ability to pursue ethics matters when the one-year limit expires or when someone has left county service.
The Council on Friday also advanced Bill 100, Committee Draft 1, 9-0 on first reading. It would set up lobbyist regulations with a maximum $5,000 administrative fine for knowing violations.
Akitake asked the Council to add language making clear the $5,000 limit applies “despite” the $1,000 cap in Section 2.56.010 of the County Code, the section Bill 55 amends.
Batangan said he would not offer that change himself but did not object to it. He said he objected to is changing the agreed-upon bill on the Council floor.
Rawlins-Fernandez said she would introduce the amendment at second reading, which she said would be on the Nov. 25 agenda.
Council meetings set for Dec. 9 and Dec. 23 round out the final meetings scheduled so far this year, according to the Council. The new Council term, with three incoming members, begins Jan. 2.











