BLNR approves $375,000 settlement with Nakoa vessel owners

The Board of Land and Natural Resources has approved a $375,000 settlement with Kevin and Kimberly Albert and the Albert Revocable Trust, for stony coral and live rock damage resulting from the February 2023 Nakoa vessel grounding incident near Honolua Bay on Maui.
At the board’s Friday, Nov. 13, 2026, meeting, Department of Land and Natural Resources Division of Aquatic Resources staff provided a review of the case history, including vessel removal, staff investigative work, dive surveys to determine natural and cultural resource damage, the community meeting and the contested case hearing. A brief procedural history:

July 28, 2023 — DLNR DAR initiated enforcement against Jim Jones, the vessel operator, Noelani Yacht Charters, LLC, Kevin Albert, Kimberly Albert and the Trust for alleged damage to live rock and coral as a result of the grounding. DAR recommended $117,471.97 in administrative fines and costs to be imposed. The board tentatively accepted a settlement with the Alberts for that amount, while reserving claims against Jones and Noelani Yacht Charters. That settlement was not finalized.
Jan. 26, 2024 — DLNR DAR returned with the enforcement action. The board deferred action and directed DAR to obtain West Maui community input based on the volume of testimony received on this item. DAR conducted a public meeting on February 22, 2024, where attendees emphasized the area’s cultural importance and sought stronger penalties and deterrence.
April 26, 2024 — Following community consultation, DAR resubmitted the action. The board increased the fine assessment to $1,818,851.97. The Alberts submitted a written contested case hearing (CCH) request on April 30, 2024, followed by a petition on May 6, 2024.
May 24, 2024 — The board denied the CCH request on procedural grounds. The Alberts appealed to the First Circuit Court on June 21, 2024. The court’s April 10, 2025 amended remand order reversed the decisions to forego a CCH and deny the request, and directed the board to conduct a CCH.
Sept. 26, 2025 — At the hearing, where Jones and Noelani Yacht Charters were admitted as parties, DLNR DAR and the Alberts reached terms on a proposed $375,000 settlement.
While the total settlement amount is lower than the board’s April 2024 assessment, it is more than three times the initial DAR staff recommendation. The current settlement reflects the severity of the violation and considers not only the tangible resources impacted – 119 stony coral colonies and 1,640.5 square meters of live rock, but the burden and emotional distress of the grounding on the West Maui community. Ocean and shoreline access from Honolua Bay to Lipoa Point was blocked for multiple weeks while defueling and salvage operations took place.
In September 2025, the United States Attorney’s Office for the District of Hawaiʻi filed charges against the Alberts in federal court under the Oil Pollution Act of 1990, to recover all removal costs incurred by the US Coast Guard in responding to the Nakoa grounding. The Alberts settled the matter in September 2026 by paying a fine of several hundred thousand dollars (See: United States of America v. Albert Revocable Trust et al., No. 1:25-cv-00400).
Together with the settlement amount in this case, the Alberts will pay almost $1,000,000 for natural resource damage caused by the grounding.
DLNR DAR staff recognizes that monetary recovery cannot fully replace the damaged resources or entirely ease community frustration but can hopefully act as a deterrent that encourages more responsible vessel management in the future.
The agreement reached last week with the BLNR resolves only the Alberts’ portion of the case. The pursuit of accountability against Jones and Noelani Yacht Charters continues and will be addressed at a future hearing.












