Search
Aloha, !
My Profile | Logout
Aloha, Guest!
Login | Register
  • News Topics
    • Front Page
    • Maui News
    • Business
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Maui Wildfires
    • Maui Election 2026
    • Food & Dining
    • Housing & Real Estate
    • Hawai‘i Journalism Initiative
    • Crime Statistics
    • Local Sports
    • Opinion
  • Weather & Surf
    • Weather Forecast
    • Surf Report
  • Lifestyle & Culture
    • History & Culture
    • Maui Arts & Entertainment
    • Food & Dining
    • Obituaries
    • Housing & Real Estate
    • Visitors' Guide
  • Events Calendar
    • Upcoming Maui Events
    • Events Map
    • Post an Event
  • Job Listings
    • Maui Jobs
    • Recent Job Listings
    • Job Alerts
    • Post a Job
  • Classifieds
    • View All
    • Post a Notice
  • Special Sections
    • Hawaii Journalism Initiative
    • History & Culture
    • Medical Minute
  • × Close Menu
  • About Maui Now
  • Newsletter
  • Contact Us
  • Get the App
  • Advertise With Us
  • Meet the Team
Choose Your Island:
  • Kauai
  • Maui
  • Big Island
Copyright © 2026 Pacific Media Group
All Rights Reserved

Privacy Policy | About Our Ads

Maui Now
Search
Aloha, !
My Profile | Logout
Aloha, Guest!
Login | Register
    Maui Now
  • Sections
  • Maui News
  • Wildfires
  • Business
  • Weather
  • Election 2026
  • Entertainment
  • Visitors' Guide
  • Jobs
  • Obituaries
  • HJI

This article brought to you in partnership with the Hawai'i Journalism Initiative — a Maui-based 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization.

Donate Learn about HJI
Hawai'i Journalism Initiative

High praise and staunch criticism show divide over the 5-year leadership of sidelined Maui Police Chief Pelletier

By Colleen Uechi
November 22, 2026, 6:00 AM HST
Share
Play
Listen to this Article
5 minutes
Loading Audio... Article will play after ad...
Playing in :00
A
A
A

KAHULUI — When Maui Police Chief John Pelletier took over the department in December 2021, eight high-ranking officers retired that same month, including Deputy Chief Dean Rickard, a 34-year veteran of the department, and assistant chiefs Victor Ramos and John Jakubczak, who had been finalists for the chief position.  

On Wednesday, Rickard, Ramos and several other retired Maui Police Department officers sat in the front rows of a Maui Police Commission meeting as Pelletier’s attorney fought to reinstate him while the commission investigates Pelletier’s oversight of a unit targeted in a federal corruption probe. 

Police Chief John Pelletier watches the Maui Police Commission’s meeting on Nov. 18, 2026. HJI / COLLEEN UECHI photo

To some of the retired officers, the investigation into Pelletier and the commission’s decision last month to put him on paid leave justified their longstanding concerns about his leadership of the department.

“We’re here to alert our community that we know when something has gone terribly awry, with a chief who now is here with an attorney, and in my opinion and our fellow retirees spanning seven decades, has gone rogue with disrespect, with defiance towards his own commission, resistance, and in my opinion, insubordination,” said Kekuhaupio Akana, a retired MPD deputy chief and Mayor Richard Bissen’s former chief of staff.

To some current officers and Pelletier’s supporters in the community, the clash was another example of the old guard’s resistance to his fight for reform.

“For years, we challenged an old-boy network where relationships and institutional loyalty could stand in the way of accountability,” said Maya Marquez, a community advocate and member of the Multi-Cultural Advisory Counsel created by Pelletier. “We wanted a chief willing to confront misconduct in his own department, even when doing so was uncomfortable. And I believe that is an important part of what Chief Pelletier has been doing.”

Pelletier has had no shortage of critics and controversy in the first five years since he was chosen from a pool of five finalists to be the Maui Police Department’s new chief in October 2021. Pelletier, a captain with 22 years of experience at the Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department, was the only candidate who was not a current or former member of the Maui Police Department.

When Pelletier was sworn in on Dec. 15, 2021, he stepped into a department that was facing a 25% staffing shortage, including 101 officer vacancies. The department also was emerging from a public scandal after footage of former Chief Tivoli Faaumu’s hit-and-run in a mall parking lot had leaked. A former officer later filed a lawsuit alleging he was “kidnapped and interrogated” by two fellow officers about the leaked video.

Pelletier pledged a “people’s department” that would improve relationships with the public, tackle more cold cases and address staffing shortages.

Police respond to a call in Wailuku on Sept. 3, 2026. HJI / COLLEEN UECHI photo

But from the beginning, his outsider status, which some had heralded as an advantage, stuck out like a sore thumb. MPD chaplain Sean Housman, who hoped and prayed for one of the local candidates, remembered Pelletier mispronouncing Hawaiian words when he first arrived and felt like he might not be the best fit. But then he watched Pelletier settle into his role and saw morale improve.

“The headwinds were strong, and yeah, the resistance was great, because people weren’t getting the way that they wanted it to be or the hopes that they had,” Housman told the Police Commission Wednesday. “But man, in the midst of that uphill climb he fought.”

But the changes Pelletier pursued started to raise concerns among longtime officers. In March 2022, three high-ranking officers who retired shortly after Pelletier took over said they feared Pelletier’s decision to shorten the police recruit academy would lower standards and jeopardize the safety of officers and the public, The Maui News reported at the time.

The retired officers said that two days after he was sworn in, Pelletier held a meeting with other MPD personnel where he reassigned all but one of the nine captains and told everyone that he would “fillet the first one” who was insubordinate under his new administration. Officers were afraid of retaliation.

“The people of Maui County deserve better from this department and this chief and deputy,” retired Lt. William Hankins told The Maui News.

Pelletier responded that standards weren’t being lowered and that the people who left MPD “are not the best barometers for the morale of this agency.”

“There’s always going to be folks that aren’t happy no matter where you are,” he told the newspaper. “You can’t do everything for everyone. But I know that there’s some folks that have gone out of their way to tell us the job that we’re doing is incredible.”

Worries over low morale continued to dog the department in June 2022, when the State of Hawai‘i Organization of Police Officers released a survey of 158 Maui police officers that found 34% were considering leaving MPD, and 62% felt Pelletier had not fostered strong morale.

In a press conference five days later, Pelletier called the survey “premature” and said organizational change takes several years.

Pelletier’s bid for change ran into a snag when his hand-picked deputy chief and fellow Las Vegas MPD veteran Charles Hank III stepped down in November 2022 after less than a year on the job. MPD spokesperson Alana Pico said at the time that his departure was not related to employee complaints against him and Pelletier, who had waived a one-year residency requirement to allow Hank to take the job.  

An investigation into the complaints, which centered on the meeting when he said he’d “fillet” insubordinate staff, found that Pelletier had likely violated the Maui County violence in the workplace policy when he yelled and swore during the meeting, although another inquiry could not substantiate all of the MPD employees’ claims. The Police Commission ultimately declined to take disciplinary action against Pelletier.

In January 2023, three female Maui police employees sued the department, alleging gender discrimination, retaliation, harassment and a hostile work environment.

MPD’s Wailuku station is seen on Sept. 3, 2026. HJI / COLLEEN UECHI photo

Former Police Commission Chair Stacey Moniz said Wednesday that the commission reviewed the complaints and “thousands of pages of investigation” and found Pelletier hadn’t done anything wrong. 

“This is the police department, not a child’s preschool,” she said. “If you haven’t heard the F word in a meeting, you’re probably not listening.”

But Butch Tam Ho, a former MPD assistant chief and homicide detective who retired over two decades ago after 30 years with the department, disagreed with Pelletier’s behavior.

“What chief would ever say something like that?” he said. 

Tam Ho said the commissioners that hired Pelletier “protected him for five years” and that “he could do no wrong” in their eyes.

Despite the employee complaints and public criticism over the department’s response to the August 2023 wildfires when Lahaina residents said police put up barricades and directed traffic into harm’s way during the evacuation, Pelletier received a favorable performance review for the year from the Police Commission in 2024.

The commission also backed him when he faced a lawsuit in March 2025 alleging that he had posed as a sheriff to a woman who claimed she had been raped by rapper Sean “Diddy” Combs. At the time, Bissen recommended that the commission place Pelletier on leave and conduct its own independent review. 

The commission chaired by Moniz voted 7-0 to keep Pelletier on the job. The lawsuit was eventually dismissed.

Police Chief John Pelletier is congratulated after the Police Commission voted not to take action against him over allegations in a lawsuit in March 2025. HJI / COLLEEN UECHI photo

Three of the commissioners at the time — Vice Chair Frank Tam, Lahela Aiwohi and Arragon “Kekoa” Mowat — are now on the current nine-member commission who voted unanimously to place Pelletier on leave on Oct. 7 while they conduct an investigation into his oversight of MPD’s Criminal Intelligence Unit. In August, federal authorities arrested and charged the unit’s leader, Lt. Michael Vaituulala, for allegedly accepting bribes to protect illegal chicken fights, drug trafficking and illegal fireworks distributors.

On Wednesday, despite threats of being sued by Pelletier’s attorney Eric Seitz, the commission chaired by Tam voted 6-1 to deny a request to reinstate him. The commission also expanded its investigation to include his Oct. 9 press conference statements accusing the mayor of being the subject of two criminal investigations and trying to influence the commission to place Pelletier on leave. Both Tam and Bissen have denied that the mayor tried to influence the commission.

The mayor and prosecuting attorney have also denied the claims that he is under investigation, and Seitz admitted Wednesday that he was not aware of any charges against the mayor.

Pelletier’s supporters — who include several current officers and community members whom he’s worked closely with since coming to Maui — said opposition to the chief was politically motivated and that the chief has been making real progress in overhauling the department.

Moniz said that when the commission was looking for a new chief, “we heard horrendous stories of what was happening in Maui Police Department, and we knew something had to change.” She wasn’t interested in an off-island candidate, but she said Pelletier stood out in his interviews. Five years later, in spite of the pushback and “ridiculous” complaints, “he has produced amazing results,” from improving patrol schedules to advancing women in leadership roles.

Lt. Christina Bonacorsi, a 20-year MPD veteran and Pelletier’s chief of staff, said she’s seen firsthand the challenges of making changes in a department “with deeply established traditions and culture.” Bonacorsi said Pelletier has faced “a lot of resistance” but that the changes he’s brought, including a new department helicopter and a K-9 unit, have increased public safety. 

Bonacorsi noted that the allegations against Vaituulala were serious but didn’t think Pelletier should take the blame, saying “there is a difference between supervising an employee and being responsible for that employee’s alleged actions.”

“I ask each of you to honestly consider whether your decision is being made in the best interest of Maui, or whether outside pressure, personal agendas or political considerations are influencing the outcome,” Bonacorsi told the commission on Wednesday.

Lt. Christina Bonacorsi (at podium) testifies before the Maui Police Commission on Nov. 18, 2026. HJI / COLLEEN UECHI photo

Under Pelletier, the department has also invested in new training and technology such as rapid DNA identification to allow them to get answers to families more quickly, said Tricia-Lee Lum Ho, who works in MPD’s Forensic Facility. She said Pelletier has made it a point to visit the morgue, listen to staff’s concerns and take action. 

“In a department that is so often forgotten, Chief Pelletier has made sure we are not,” Lum Ho said.

In the community, Marquez said she has also seen a difference in her outreach with the houseless community. Through the Multi-Cultural Advisory Counsel, which aims to give voice to marginalized groups, she said she has developed relationships with MPD and gotten better access to answers about deaths in the community or help filing police reports.

She was supportive of the commission investigating the Vaituulala case, but she saw his arrest as “the kind of accountability we have been demanding” and didn’t think Pelletier should shoulder the blame for his lieutenant’s actions.

“When officers entrusted with extraordinary authority are held accountable for alleged criminal conduct, that should not automatically be treated as a failure of leadership,” Marquez said.

But Pelletier’s detractors — who include retired veteran Maui police officers and community members concerned about MPD’s handling of cases — see Pelletier as the root cause of the department’s problems.

“A chief of police who has refused to take any responsibility whatsoever,” said Akana, who retired in 2006 after 25 years with MPD. “… It is his watch. It is his command. It is his Criminal Intelligence Unit. … How did this public corruption scandal happen by a commander who worked directly for the office of the chief?”

Akana said that retired officers “do not lay claim that in our era we were better cops or that our leaders were better than the leaders today.” However, he disagreed with Pelletier’s defiance toward the commission and described him as “a cultic personality” who “would rather divide our community.”

Several retired MPD officers attended the Police Commission meeting on Nov. 18, 2026, including former Deputy Chief Dean Rickard (in red) and former assistant chief Victor Ramos (right of Rickard). HJI / COLLEEN UECHI photo

Rickard did not criticize Pelletier directly but supported the investigation, telling the commission that “no individual should be above accountability because of rank, position or title.”

“When questions are raised, they must be examined, and when facts are proven, they must guide the outcome,” Rickard said. “At its core, this matter reaches beyond any single person or office. It touches the foundation of public trust.”

Elizabeth and Dennis Galloway’s trust in the department was shaken when their Kahului home was damaged by an illegal aerial firework on Jan. 1. Vaituulala was suspended briefly after he was reportedly spotted in the background of a video with the fireworks going off. The Galloways said he did nothing to stop it. 

Dennis Galloway said said they have endured 10 months of “mental and physical anguish” waiting to see accountability for the incident. MPD told them in July that the case had been forwarded to the prosecutor’s office. In the meantime, “watching the corruption of a few police officers before our eyes is mind-blowing,” he said. 

“They have proven that they cannot properly and honestly complete investigations, nor can they be trusted,” Elizabeth Galloway added.

Maui resident Kahala Johnson also raised concerns about MPD’s budget, which has grown from about $62 million when Pelletier first became chief to more than $117 million in the current fiscal year. Johnson wondered what benefits “the most vulnerable and unsafe kanaka maoli in our community” were getting, when so much effort has gone toward MPD sweeping unsheltered communities and expanding surveillance technology.

“Millions of dollars have been spent on surveillance for our communities in the name of security, while alleged criminal corruption flourishes within the department’s own intelligence unit,” Johnson said. “Consider what the $55 million in the past five years could have accomplished instead.”

MPD officers clear a homeless encampment in Kahului in July 2025. HJI / COLLEEN UECHI photo

Some think Pelletier has never gotten a fair shake since he arrived and that the mayor has opposed his leadership from the start because of his close connections to former MPD officers like Ramos, whom he supported for chief, and commissioners who have donated to his campaign, including Aiwohi, Joseph Arias, Don Cameron II and Shackley Raffetto.

Tam stated emphatically Wednesday that the decision to place Pelletier on leave was about protecting the integrity of the investigation and that he had not been influenced by the mayor.

Bissen’s administration has also denied that the mayor tried to influence the commission, with his spokesperson Laksmi Abraham noting that he has publicly committed to working with the police chief and has supported Pelletier’s requests for investments in MPD.

Commissioner Eugene Santiago, who retired as a MPD sergeant detective in 2012 after 30 years of service, said the commission is simply interested in getting to the bottom of what Pelletier knew in the Vaituulala case.  

Santiago said: “The foundation of what we’re here for is accountability.”

Colleen Uechi
Colleen Uechi is the editor of the Hawai’i Journalism Initiative. She formerly served as managing editor of The Maui News and staff writer for The Molokai Dispatch. She grew up on O’ahu.
Read Full Bio

Comments

This comments section is a public community forum for the purpose of free expression. Although Maui Now encourages respectful communication only, some content may be considered offensive. Please view at your own discretion. View Comments

Help Fund Local Journalism

Learn More about HJI
  • One-Time
  • Monthly
  • Yearly

One-Time Donation Amount

$500
$250
$100
$50
$25
$

Monthly Donation Amount

$500 / month
$250 / month
$100 / month
$50 / month
$20 / month
$
/month

Yearly Donation Amount

$500 / year
$250 / year
$100 / year
$50 / year
$25 / year
$
/year

Share this article

×
HJI Donate Modal

PARDON THE INTERRUPTION

HJI Logo

Help Support Independent
Journalism on Maui

Hawaii Journalism Initiative (HJI) is a nonprofit newsroom dedicated to in-depth, public-service journalism focused on Maui County.

Our reporting is free to read on Maui Now, and made possible entirely by donations.

What is HJI? How are Maui Now and HJI related?
Donate Now Continue Reading

What is HJI?

The Hawaii Journalism Initiative (HJI) is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit newsroom dedicated to in-depth, public-service journalism focused on Maui County. We produce accountability reporting, investigative stories, and coverage of issues that matter to our community.

HJI is entirely donor-supported. Our work is free to read and made possible by people who value independent local news.

How are Maui Now and HJI related?

Maui Now is the primary publishing platform for the Hawaii Journalism Initiative. HJI’s stories appear on Maui Now so readers can access them in one place alongside other local news and information.

While Maui Now hosts the content, HJI is the nonprofit that funds and produces this independent journalism. Donations to HJI directly support that reporting.

Arrow UpBack to Top
  • Maui News
  • Maui Business
  • Weather
  • Entertainment
  • Maui Surf
  • Maui Sports
  • Crime Statistics
  • Best Maui Activities
  • Maui Discussion
  • Food and Dining
  • Housing & Real Estate
  • Maui Events Calendar
  • Maui Jobs
  • Official Visitors’ Guide
  • Hawai‘i Journalism Initiative
  • About Maui Now
  • Contact Information
  • Advertise with Us
  • App
  • Newsletter
  • Terms of Service
  • Hawaii Now – Statewide News

Copyright © 2026 Pacific Media Group.
All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | About Our Ads

Facebook YouTube Instagram